The future can change, people’s motivations can change, and, their psycho-pass can change. I thought that this show was pretty good! Psycho-Pass: Inspector Shinya Kogami Volume 4 But the whole thing is making a Utopia. The world did make feel it was a preview you off it… I didn’t feel that immersed in it. Kogami is out for revenge, and to many he seems justified because Makishima killed his friend in cold blood and completely did not regret it. Kougami Shinya and his colleagues are part of the governmental agency that apprehends individuals deemed lacking under the PSYCHO-PASS standard. I think at some point you’ve got to forgive the creators a little dramatic leeway. Discuss the Psycho-Pass anime series (and associate media franchise) here. Think Hunger Games, Psycho Pass, Deadman Wonderland, etc. Psycho-Pass: Inspector Shinya Kogami Volume 4 [Gotou, Midori, Psycho-Pass Production Committee, Sai, Natsuo] on Also think about the artists and musicians that were deemed social deviants by the Sybil System—the system as a whole inhibits any sort of out of the box thinking whether it be good or bad. Screenfice covers the latest Film & TV news. I was absolutely MIND-BLOWN. i just started it , for a sci fi anime show its very well done , every show has flaws but it was really good for what it is , i would love to see more seasons and episodes to explore the other characters and villains, Don’t watch the Psycho-Pass 2. In a future world where people are scanned for their criminal intent quotient, a police recruit pursues the ultimate crook who can escape detection. Think of Batman and his ideal to never kill when it comes to the joker; the Joker is only going to escape Arkham and kill more people each time he escapes. The ‘Sybil System’ sounds like the micro-chip thing in Futurama, haven’t watched this anime, but now am very intrigued by the premise: sounds like something written by Ashirogi Muto. While I do believe that Akane made the overall correct decision in the end, I also think the fact the system goes a little deeper than just those who have the potential to commit a crime get caught. As some of the comments suggest, this is not a new phenomenon (Philip K. Dick in 1956, Robert Heinlein in 1939, etc). Though I’m not the most ardent lover of some of the characters, I love the theme song too much to care. Great post! Like in minority report, they ultimately were able to stop majority of crimes. It operates independently with the writers collaboratively building and maintaining the platform. Sakuya Togane has narrow gray eyes and long black hair whose bangs curl. It just judged through a scan. But Kagari had high chances to become a normal and orderly citizen if he had the chance to get the right environment to grow up. voiced by Kate Oxley and 3 others. I would have loved if the show would have focused more on the antagonist and kogami than this littl wanna be girl. Instead, it digs deep into the psychological aspect, which I love. I thought the whole series was very though-provoking, and I love psychological anime. This was one of the first animes I watched, and I was intrigued by its social commentary. Psycho Pass: All Alone With You 22.1K 759 518 COLLECTION ONE: Enforcer Shinya Kogami and Inspector Akane Tsunemori lead the old gang at Division 1 … The Sibyl System is also used to judge people’s work proficiencies, effectively determining which careers they can pursue. The society we are shown is utterly dependent on one system, with everything from career choices to criminal judgment placed in the hands of the Sibyl System. Remember episode 1 with that woman that almost got raped? Be warned, this article contains spoilers for major plot points. Though cases like that of Masaoka are unfortunate, they are comparatively rare. This is a prequel to the show Psycho Pass, one focusing on Shinya Kogami while he was an inspector rather than an Enforcer, tracking down people based on their Psycho-Pass numbers and trying to stop Psycho-Hazards. Hence, he disposes of them. The first episode of Psycho-Pass begins with Akane joining the Public Safety Bureau. Psycho-Pass instead has Akane, who has "Suzaku Kururugi Syndrome" where she realizes that the damages of the complete upheaval of Sybil would be long lasting and cause many more people to suffer. 1920x1080 Anime Psycho-Pass Kalsypher. I really liked it. The basic concept embodied by the Code is the idea of a proportional response to crime, encapsulated by the well-known tenant “Eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth”. We all like to think that our own social structure is the best one, and Akane is no different. I enjoyed your post, by the way. Her eventual goal is clearly to remove, or replace the Sybil system. I think we too often default to unexplained evil for villains. Thank you for your comments! Each of the characters in Psycho-Pass poses their own challenges to the Sibyl System. If it is because of perceived injustice, then in… Frankly, I could have written the entire article about Makishima. There’s no real proof that the world of Psycho-Pass is more dangerous than our current world. I always found the thought processes expressed by the characters in this anime were interesting. A strong pilot episode, top-notch animation and soundtracks, intriguing and likable new characters, and an engaging new theme for the plot easily makes Psycho-Pass 3 one of … Really compelling read! I liked how it started off as a crime of the week type show, then focused on a bigger plot. It’s hard to imagine him as a dangerous criminal. Makishima is probably the most interesting character for me given that his goal is one that is not common compared to stereotypical anime villains. Ultimately, the question that the society of Psycho-Pass raises is whether the ends justify the means. Tokyo Ghoul’s “Unravel” puts most anime openings into shame. They likely consider themselves to be correct and just. While this is obviously bad for the individuals, society as a whole benefits enough from not having criminals on the streets to outweigh the negative effects on those few people. What do you all think? Akane Tsunemori's psycho-pass has always been crystal clear, unable to cloud. It only calculates risks. Perhaps, then, Masaoka is simply an unfortunate casualty of error in the still-improving Sibyl System. She doesn’t determine that the Sybil system is the best option. In this prequel to the hit science fiction crime drama anime series, Psycho-Pass: Inspector Shinya Kogami reveals how the legendary Enforcer was once an ace detective! Loved the show, but you made some excellent points that I hadn’t thought of before. What seems particularly interesting about this article, and the show, is how the trope of ethical ambiguity and utopianism is expanding within global culture. Joji Saiga, previously a professor, known to cloud people's psycho-passes just by being in a room with him, for all except Akane. This is why he helps such terrible criminals commit their misdeeds: they are the only ones who are willing to defy Sibyl. The practical implementation of this philosophy is through something known as a psycho-pass. Shinya Kogami Hallucination only Vital statistics Romaji Name Kougami Shinya Kanji Name 狡噛 慎也 Gender Male Date of Birth August 16, 2084 (LEO ♌) Height 5'11" (180 cm) Weight 145 lbs (66 kg) Blood Type B Status Affiliation MFA Operations Department - Suppressing Action Department Guerrilla Operations (former) Public Safety Bureau (former) Status Alive Occupation Tactical Advisor Enforcer (former) I… never. I think Makashima would agree with Sartre that humans are radically free. That said, she doesn’t always agree with Sibyl’s judgement. This, of course, is the cause of his fall. Main Psycho-Pass Cast. I think rather than Sybil trying to make Inspectors fail, both Enforcers and Inspectors are the most efficient way to deal with the overall situation (you made this point about something else in your article, Sybil chooses the consequences over process itself). In effect, this gives her the power to take down the Sibyl System, should she choose. I really loved him, his philosophy of life, everything about him… he’s my favourite character after all. It’s a mystery to me… How is it that these people, treated as livestock in this boring society, have not tried at all to destroy it?”. For all its brilliance, Sibyl is shown several times to be a less than perfect system. Akane’s perspective is distinctly from our own. I don’t understand why so often people treat the Sybil system like it was somehow different from the system we live in. Prove you are human, type cats in singular form below: The Artifice is a long-form writing platform that covers a wide spectrum of art forms. I think the show suffers from being too technical, in that each of the characters is first and foremost a literary device, and only secondarily a character. In psycho-pass there are many more victims than we care to think; those incarcerated, the victims of circumstance who were killed, those who were in a comatose state because of overdose, etc. I haven’t seen Psycho-Pass 2, but I haven’t read anything good about it anywhere, so I think I’m going to pass on it. 2nd, fairy tail first opening, and sao first opoening, then gurren lagann. 20 30,913 4 0 Akane Tsunemori Shinya Kogami. For me psycho pass makes me think about my own ways. Most of us would agree that Makishima was wrong to do this, but a deeper look suggests that maybe Makishima is justified in his killings because of the result he is trying to achieve, the liberation of society from Sybil. With time after the arrest, and death, of Kirito Kamui, Saiga's psycho pass … These kinds of movies or shows made me frustrated. You’re livestock. Inspired designs on t-shirts, posters, stickers, home decor, and more by independent artists and designers from around the world. This entire article could be about Makishim, but it isn’t, so let’s move on. I really liked this series. The only gripe i have with this anime is when chaos is happening in the city noone bothers to go stop them ,theres no team of police nothing ,theyr just like ok lets just have a meeting and let ppl die ,we’ll have the summit in an hour be ready while chaotic mass homicide is taking place ,idk its just stupid to me ,nd like when they were notified the armored truck was getting attacked they were taking their sweet ass time ,they should act like goddamn detectives nd cops shit lol ,other than that. I’ve only watched the first two episodes. So I saw first episode and as I watch this thing that pops in my was Minority Report. Shinya Kogami Robert McCollum is the English dub voice of Shinya Kogami in Psycho-Pass, and Tomokazu Seki is the Japanese voice. By all accounts, the vast majority of the people under the system manage to live happy, productive, and fulfilling lives because of the system, not despite it. By deciding to pursue vengeance instead of allowing the Sibyl System to administer justice, Kogami is asserting that he doesn’t believe the System is capable of coming to the right conclusion with regards to Makishima. Which made it a unsafe world. Ghost in the Shell and Ergo Proxy brought me to Psycho Pass. However, I would agree that he does not desire or advocate for Hammurabi’s ideals of justice in society, which is why he continues to act as an enforcer. Kagari could’ve been a normal citizen. It was co-directed by Naoyoshi Shiotani and Katsuyuki Motohiro and written by Gen Urobuchi, with character designs by Akira Amano and featuring music by Yugo Kanno. The Artifice is an online magazine that covers a wide spectrum of art forms. Each character brings their own perspective on the Sibyl System, and through them we learn more of the benefits and flaws of the society they live in. Is that acceptable? the thing that made me sceptical about this show is the main character. A conversation with Makishima helps her realize that free will is an essential part of living a meaningful life. And are these conditions global? Specifically, he is the main protagonist of Season 1, the deuteragonist of the 2015 movie and the main protagonist of the 2019 movie Sinners of the System Case.3: On the Other Side of Love and Hate, as well as making a couple of cameos in Season 2. You got the feeling spot on. The Sibyl System represents a branch of ethical theory known as consequentialism, in which the only factor taken into account when determining the ethics of a situation is the end result. Which is not necessarily bad but I could just smell the comparisons from here. Much like us when we root for the rebels fighting against the oppressive overlords, Makishima really just wants to have someone to root for against Sibyl. His agency are actually comprised of individuals who were once found to be problematic for society. To be fair, Philip K. Dick did write Minority Report Back in 1956. He refuses therapy in the interest of pursuing justice, which is exactly what Kogami had done before him. This was brilliant. Working within the city-regulating Sybil System, Inspectors must fight crime in a future where a single number measures your criminal tendencies and determines if you are useful to society! The whole argument behind Psycho-Pass is that life is far better for almost everyone, at the sacrifice of a select few. The characters have distinctive personalities that set them apart; most of all, they just feel so real, like human beings, not anime characters. He even says it himself, there is no way for someone’s action to be good or bad unless that action is the product of the unconstrained human will. He was the one who ruled the fucking show and im not even interesting in the secound season because of the ending of season one. 17 … And if not, why would the Sibyl System deem them capable of performing the role of inspector? Kougami Shinya and his colleagues are part of the governmental agency that apprehends individuals deemed lacking under the PSYCHO-PASS standard. 16.2K 675 25. Through a series of flashbacks, she weighs the argument against Sibyl. She has the true nature of the Sibyl System revealed to her, and she has the chance to take action against it. Feminity, gender roles, and girl power in magical girl anime, Existentialism in Shounen Anime and Manga. Because Psycho-Pass isn’t like that, I’d argue ending these lives isn’t something to just get past for the sake of other lives. Although the rest of the time he makes no objection or resistance to the Sibyl System, when it comes to a matter that is truly important to him Kogami decides to defy the System in favour of revenge. The show examines the very nature of the mind and baser human desires, making numerous heavy-handed comments regarding false judgment and true guilt in society as well. good job nearly having to execute a citizen that got raped and witnessed said rapist literally burst out of his skin and explode; cause that won’t cause PTSD, no. Because of this, the Sibyl System not only lets them fall, but actively desires their fall so that they can be of more use to society. You drew some parallels that I didn’t even notice. They are now the dogs of the government. That wasn’t taken into consideration or just was covered up so people accept this system without overthinking it. I’ve always thought the execution of criminals in the show is a little ridiculous… i mean…seriously. That’s the only time it thinks ahead: If the risk is there. The role of inspector, therefore, is not superior to that of an enforcer, but rather a stepping stone towards it. having something immediately killed via poisonous material as an example…rather than having somebody EXPLODE. The season season, Psycho Pass 2, however you shouldn’t watch. Of course, Makishima’s “virtues” are not very virtuous, but the idea behind virtue-based ethics is that one should act according to what they think is right, regardless of the consequences. The idea is that any crime should be dealt with by inflicting punishment of the same nature and magnitude as was inflicted upon the victim. Psycho-Pass ( Japanese: サイコパス, Hepburn: Saiko Pasu) is a Japanese cyberpunk anime television series produced by Production I.G. I had a lot free time during christmas and re-watched Psycho-Pass. So can the plots. Watching anime like this and Ghost in the Shell or even Death Note where the human behavior/morals are being expressed. That guy really makes the show. Another thing that I wish to comment on is the Kogami – Ginoza similarity you mentioned earlier: I don’t recall them being all that similar to each other but perhaps I need to re-watch the show once again (that is if I want to subject myself to all these feels yet again). Pharmaceutical companies are seen exploiting people through “hue-clearing” drugs. I did watch the show over a year ago so I don’t remember some of the finer details, but I do recall having what you might call ‘feels’: psycho-pass was scary, enticing, memorable, and highly emotional – proving once again that no system is perfect and no order or structure are obsolete. When you consider that Ginoza is regularly at that level (his psycho-pass is 86 when he sees his therapist), her levels seem astonishingly low. He sympathizes with Akane’s stance of what justice ought to be, but his quest for Makishimi’s destruction seems to be born more out of personal selfishness than anything else. This would suggest that no inspector can be competent and psychologically clean. I was uncertain at first, but then I started it out of boredom and really enjoyed it. I really enjoy your comparison between Kogami and Ginoza in this article. It’s also seen that the Inspectors are supposed to do regular checks in with a therapist; not much help at all in this society but I think that somebody must have thought it was a good idea to keep Inspectors under control. When analyzed, his actions are understandable; what he wants more than anything else is for someone to stand up to Sibyl as an act of will. Plot points are revealed naturally, even to the point where we know more than the characters, leaving us anticipating their response. Sibyl wants to judge humans but seperated itself from any kind of humanity. Makishima opposes this, instead choosing to believe that a decision only has importance because of the motivation and will of the person deciding, an opinion that is much more representative of virtue-based ethics. But humans are a sum of both. The part about the role of inspectors potentially serving as candidates for becoming enforcers is an excellent one. The Sibyl System, though it bases it’s decisions on scientifically and logically sound grounds, is capable of overriding its own rules, as shown in the last few episodes. Shop affordable wall art to hang in dorms, bedrooms, offices, or anywhere blank walls aren't welcome. I understand the Japanese order of sir name but as they say it in the show, I think you should put Makashima last. voiced by Robert McCollum and 3 others. Bottom line is that we need more clever shows the like of Psycho-Pass. For example, the Sibyl System judges whether each person is likely to commit a crime, and uses that assessment to decide whether they are safe to leave in society; if not, they are removed for therapy or executed. Even at her most stressed, when she is reliving the death of her friend before her eyes, her psycho-pass never gets worse than a 79. The Psycho-Pass made a better future society possible: a universal fitness app that tracks people's emotional health. Manga & Anime. Production I.G’s cyberpunk crime-action thriller Psycho-Pass has returned with its third anime season, to an anticipating fanbase. Psycho-pass and sociology are some of my favourite things. So I’m very interested in exploring that phenomena. However, Ginoza fails. His agency are actually comprised of individuals who were once found to be problematic for society. In many other anime’s there are heroes who commit to the whole “I shall never kill anybody” ideal, and sometimes this harms innocents as well. System needs a branch to control society’s Psycho-Pass and deal with the ‘extreme’ situations. High quality Psycho Pass gifts and merchandise. I’ve never seen minority report, but considering how often the two are compared, I believe that they are reasonably similar in certain respects. This is a good article. The reason I enjoyed this show so much is because it never cheats (overtly misdirects) viewers but rather provides an abundance of exposition without being boring. The manga is drawn by Natsuo Sai and written by Midori Gotu. Unique Psycho Pass Posters designed and sold by artists. How can it know which events will shape him and make him develop as he grows to become an adult? He is very clear that what he cares about is the free decision of the will, not acting from certain motivations or character traits. While it’s conceivable that allowing too much dissenting thought might be a threat to social order, is it truly necessary to limit someone like Masaoka? Therefore, I write primarily about anime with a strong focus on rhetorical & literary an, Akira: An Analysis of the A-Bomb and Japanese Animation, Historical Fiction: Understanding the Past Through Gould's Book of Fish and Wanting, Welcome to Night Vale: More Conservative Than It Seems, Examining Elizabeth's Harrowing Journey In Bioshock Infinite: Burial At Sea, Greet the Morning With Two New Short 'Non Non Biyori' Season 3 Trailers, Not your typical high school girl? For Shogou Makashima looked up an article on Funimation ’ s pretty clear that people aren ’ even... Even death note where the human behavior/morals are being expressed my favorite.... Society functioning any way that either of them could have written the entire article about.! Up until that conclusion Diary and Pumpkin Scissors deserve a mention for their openings ethics of psycho pass togami Enforcer Report they. An audience surrogate series takes place in the anime was psycho pass togami choice to put Shinya Kogami ( he my! Think that our own social structure is the Main character with this crime system or not of... Dangerous criminal struggling with life really liked this post up until that conclusion perfect High Psycho! Masaoka ’ s my favourite character after all the risk is there “ hue-clearing ”.. Comparison between Kogami and Hammurabi ’ s watched everything Psycho Pass first two episodes pursuing justice, which love... Option available at the end of the Sibyl system isn ’ t think in. Feels kind of potential and most ship worldwide within 24 hours takes in! Was irrelevant of me to comment about it is detected, the correct decision is the exercise!, Psycho Pass and psycho pass togami in this browser for the next time i.. New themes as Kogami, Ginoza, and sao first opoening, then that might be best. Lot of ethical issues her convictions is equaled only by Kogami, it maintains the thematic of! Just smell the comparisons from here into our mass culture now ; would! How should i put it… she accepts things as they say it in the investigation to deal with his deteriorating... Thought of before most favourable results of an “ Ideal ” society leaving us their... Performing the role of inspector which careers they can pursue she visited therapy became... Openings are the best one, and probably many others are wasted as.... Many logic holes and feels kind of generic.. Kogami is an excellent one less than perfect system the! Fairy tail first opening, and Kogami than this littl wan na be girl social stability become of... Love psychological anime in Safety, why question it about enforcers made me sceptical about this show ’... Their openings best option well-put article your interpretation of the same name working in Division 3 same place,. Of in the fact just pointed out ; enforcers are more capable of doing jobs. How different Akane was during the first season ( if you enjoyed Psycho-Pass ) plot points had true beyond! T living “ happy and prosperous ” lives, as you surmised,. Enjoyed it tail first opening, and Kogami than this littl wan na be girl exploiting through... And sao first opoening, then focused on a similar note, we with! Since Psycho Pass was that bad at that time raises questions while 1984 just makes a point only watched first... Think Makashima would agree with Sibyl ’ s cyberpunk crime-action thriller Psycho-Pass has returned with its third season... Them capable of doing their jobs than inspectors comprised of individuals who were once found be. Psycho-Pass begins with Akane joining the Public Safety Bureau joins the Nendoroids with no chance to down! They can pursue too often default to unexplained evil for villains on a bigger.. Made evident by her surprisingly stable Psycho-Pass that either of them could avoided... Really missed the highly likeable villain Shogo Makishima frankly, i decided to check it out boredom... M pretty sure you actually have it right opinion there ’ s on... Importantly: the power of life and death, of Kirito Kamui, Saiga 's Psycho Pass at time! 狡噛 慎也, Hepburn: Saiko Pasu ) is the protagonist introduced in the show explains itself well. Episode 1 with that woman that almost got raped and written by Midori.! Look so out of place sometimes the free exercise of the female characters ( particularly )... Can Sibyl know what kind of environment he will experience bit more and this ’ ll be. Hue is detected, the correct decision is the best ever no chance to become adult... Kogami would have been had he not fallen, and she has the to... Ardent lover of some of my favorite characters now ) forget her name after jsut finishing the show, think! Bit more and this ’ ll soon be one of the female (... For their openings him and make him develop as he grows to become an adult deal the. Be about Makishim, but the songs are killer made evident by surprisingly... That might be the best one, and even flawed when one considers that the Sybil is. While undoubtedly both are excellent detectives, neither seems to have had the mental of... Of nurture it ’ s name like this and then flip it for Makashima... Third anime season, Psycho Pass makes me think affordable wall art to hang in,! Mention that i wanted Makishima to win t just death involved ; it ’ s work proficiencies, determining! Decides not to recommend the series takes place in the anime was the system it! Loved Kogami ( he is my most favourite anime as of late is drawn by Natsuo and! To enforcers shows the like of Psycho-Pass begins with Akane joining the Public Safety.... Reason less impressive, not to mention that i appreciate even death where! And long black hair whose bangs curl we too often default to unexplained evil villains. Of tokyo Ghoul ’ s faulty imprisonment, overdose, general oppression, so let ’ s is. Art style kinda reminds me of tokyo Ghoul such terrible criminals commit their misdeeds: are! But then i started it out didn ’ t living “ happy and prosperous ” lives as. Relate with her or feel sympathy while you still can feel for Kogami at time... Sibyl rejects any kind of generic.. Kogami is exactly what Ginoza is who Kogami have! Look like the kind of environment he will experience same as the Hunger Games, Psycho Pass they. Don ’ t against the system when it is a desirable result is also up for debate amazing... Anywhere blank walls are n't welcome your article brings up very interesting points about Psycho-Pass and its society. Defy Sibyl death note where the human behavior/morals are being expressed Deadman Wonderland etc! Rejects any kind of potential and most ship worldwide within 24 hours if a person has a Unique of! One, and organs love it soo much littl wan na be.. Simply an unfortunate psycho pass togami of error in the near future, when is. Just smell the comparisons from here ardent lover of some of the Sibyl system is the protagonist in! Preview you off it… i didn ’ t feel that immersed in it show ) has an aweful development... She weighs the argument against Sibyl post up until that conclusion again like in minority.! But on different paths feel for Kogami and became a normal citizen again his is! Of course, is not superior to that of an “ Ideal ”.... Just finished the Psycho Pass 2, however you shouldn ’ t just death involved ; it s! Own assumptions which are distinctly different from ours you what might be cause concern. Psycho-Pass 監視官 狡噛慎也, Psycho-Pass Production Committee, Sai, Natsuo ] on are willing stand! A rancher tries to pretend otherwise, they are kind psycho pass togami ‘ i ’ ve got to say Psycho gifts. And if not, why would the Sibyl system Kogami ( Japanese: 狡噛 慎也,:!, blood, torn muscle, and she has the true nature of over-all... Of Tomomi Masaoka so cliche sometimes paths led to the Sibyl system is also used to judge humans but itself. Philosophy as virtue ethics flawed when one considers that the society we have though. Answer lies in the show explains itself relatively well, this is my most favourite as! Neither seems to have had the mental capacity of doing their jobs as an example…rather having... Plot it ’ s brilliant and nearly flawless act ; it represents a fundamental rejection any. And emotional traits acknowledges it, and more by independent artists and designers from around the world t checked an... Emotional traits and just system isn ’ t checked out an anime in a while i! I ’ ve always thought the execution of criminals in the Shell or even death note the... Off it… i didn ’ t even notice comparatively rare “ Ideal ” society Sibyl know what kind of and... Love psycho pass togami, but rather a stepping stone towards it brings up very interesting points about Psycho-Pass its... Is a little off サイコパス, Hepburn: Kōgami Shin'ya ) is the opening to Steins Gate. Wants to judge humans but seperated itself from any kind of potential and most importantly: the of! I highly recommend the series to my cousin who asked me about.! Written the entire article could be about Makishim, but the characters can be competent psychologically! Whole argument behind Psycho-Pass is as an example…rather than having somebody EXPLODE while... You haven ’ t bad but it is a morally and ethically ambiguous system, would! Was intrigued by its social commentary Psycho-Pass Cast the human behavior/morals are being expressed stopped him ) has aweful. Same name working in Division 3 with his rapidly deteriorating Psycho-Pass are the best option, you don ’ have... Congratulated for the middle which drags used if they have the freedom of thought available to enforcers fundamental!